Donn's Auto Service Inc.
Middleton, WI
MechanicRank lists 6 auto repair businesses in Middleton, WI. 6 run auto repair shops you can drive to. The best rated with a real review history is Donn's Auto Service Inc., at 4.9 stars from 193 reviews. Every listing shows the phone number, hours and reviews. Or send one free quote request and a local mechanic calls you back.
Tell us what the car is doing. A local mechanic calls you back, most requests get a call back the same day. No fee, no obligation.
6 pinned locations · open the full MechanicRank map →
6 independent businesses in our directory.
Independent shops in Wisconsin usually charge $90 to $130 an hour for labor, which is below the national average. A quote is the book time for the job times that rate, plus parts. At Wisconsin rates, a transmission fluid change runs about $120 to $355 and an alternator replacement runs about $270 to $775 for a midsize car.
6 businesses in Middleton have at least 15 reviews, enough for a rating to mean something, and 6 of those hold 4.5 stars or better. Half of them have 173 or more reviews. A shop with a long history and a 4.6 is a safer call than a perfect 5.0 from a handful of people.
Wisconsin has no safety inspection for passenger cars. Vehicles kept in Kenosha, Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Racine, Sheboygan, Washington and Waukesha counties need an emissions test every other year before plates can be renewed. Model years 1996 and newer are covered, and a test is also needed within 45 days of some title changes. Details are on the Wisconsin Department of Transportation, Division of Motor Vehicles site. A shop cannot do repairs the customer has not approved, and it must write up a signed repair order before work that may cost more than $50. The shop must return replaced parts if the customer asks before the repair starts. Read the rule.
Lows drop to freezing on about 146 nights a year. Cold is when a weak battery finally fails, because a cold engine takes more power to turn over. Middleton averages 38 inches of snow, and road salt eats brake lines, exhaust and the underside of the car. Rinse the underbody through the winter and have the brake lines looked at whenever the car is up on a lift.
The average commute in Middleton is 19 minutes each way, and 70% of workers drive there alone.
Sources, checked October 13, 2026
Buying a used car in Middleton? PPI Auto, our sister company, sends an inspector to the car for $225 on most cars, pickups and SUVs. That is a 122 point check with a full scan and a road test, and the report comes back the same day. Dealer lot, private seller or auction, it works the same.
There are 63 car lots within 8 miles of Middleton, and 38 of them sell used. PPI Auto grades 44 of them A to F from their reviews, and 1 get an F. See the Madison dealer grades before you go look at a car.
Parts of Wisconsin require an emissions test. Ask the seller for the last test report, and if the check engine light is on, walk away until someone has read the code.
We list 6 in Middleton, WI. That covers mobile mechanics, workshops, diesel and heavy duty specialists, body shops and tire shops. Every one has its own page with the phone number, what they work on and the reviews we have found.
Donn's Auto Service Inc. currently holds the highest rating in Middleton at 4.9 stars from 193 reviews. Donn's Auto Service Inc., Aeschbach Automotive, Bennett's Auto Repair LLC are the top three by rating among businesses with a real review history behind them. We rank on the ratings themselves and nobody can pay to appear there.
Independent shops in Wisconsin usually bill $90 to $130 an hour for labor. The national range is $95 to $140. Dealers charge more. Most quotes are the book time for the job times that rate, plus parts, so ask the shop how many hours it is billing you for.
Wisconsin has no safety inspection for passenger cars. Vehicles kept in Kenosha, Milwaukee, Ozaukee, Racine, Sheboygan, Washington and Waukesha counties need an emissions test every other year before plates can be renewed. Model years 1996 and newer are covered, and a test is also needed within 45 days of some title changes.
Look at the review count as well as the stars, because five stars from four people tells you very little. None of the 6 listings in Middleton has been claimed yet, so call to confirm hours and what the shop works on. A shop cannot do repairs the customer has not approved, and it must write up a signed repair order before work that may cost more than $50. The shop must return replaced parts if the customer asks before the repair starts. Get the quote in writing before any work starts.
Middleton gets about 146 nights a year at or below freezing and 38 inches of snow. Cold exposes a weak battery, and salted roads rust brake lines and exhaust parts. Test the battery in the fall and rinse the underbody in winter.
Yes. PPI Auto, our sister company, inspects used cars in Middleton for $225 on most cars, pickups and SUVs. The inspector comes to the car, runs a 122 point check and sends the report the same day. Call 951-267-8500 to book.
No luck in Middleton? A mobile mechanic from the next town over will often make the trip. See all 201 cities in Wisconsin.
Madison, WITop rated: Capitol Tire and Auto Repair Service 4.9★Waunakee, WITop rated: David’s Certified Auto Repair 4.6★Cross Plains, WITop rated: Mike's Mobil LLC 4.6★Verona, WITop rated: Integrity 1st Mobile RV Service 5.0★Fitchburg, WITop rated: Capitol City Auto 4.7★DeForest, WITop rated: Anything Automotive Auto Repair & Fleet Services 5.0★McFarland, WITop rated: Ken's Automotive Services 4.9★Oregon, WITop rated: Dupy's Service Center 5.0★Typical independent shop prices at Wisconsin labor rates, parts and labor, for a midsize car. Each guide shows the price for your vehicle and what to ask before you pay. See all 97 repair cost guides.
Claim your free listing to add photos, services, and hours, and stand out from every other shop in Middleton with a Mechanic Rank certification.
Not on this page? Add your business free, we review every submission by hand before it goes live.