Need Work Done in Utica? Get a Free Quote.

Tell us what the car is doing. A local mechanic calls you back, most requests get a call back the same day. No fee, no obligation.

💬 Request a Mechanic Quote →
Service Types 5

The Highest Rated Auto Repair in Utica

Ranked by the rating and review count on each listing, not by who pays us. Nobody pays us.

  1. Meolas Auto Repair★ 5.015 reviews · Repair Shop
  2. Advent Auto Styling & Customization★ 4.9182 reviews · Repair Shop
  3. Oriskany Garage Tire & Auto Service★ 4.81,022 reviews · Tire Shop
  4. In-Tune Automotive★ 4.841 reviews · Repair Shop
  5. Monopoli's Auto Repair★ 4.743 reviews · Specialty

The best reviewed business in Utica right now is Meolas Auto Repair, at 5.0 stars across 15 reviews. Every shop above clears 4.3 stars with at least 15 reviews behind it, which is the point where a rating starts meaning something. Plenty of shops hold five stars on four reviews. That is not the same thing.

Of the 15 businesses listed in Utica, there are 2 that will come to you, 7 with a workshop you drive to and 4 tire shops. None has been claimed by its owner yet, so the hours and phone numbers come from public records. An unclaimed listing is not a worse business. It just means we built the record and nobody has corrected it yet.

Map of Mechanics in Utica

15 pinned locations · open the full MechanicRank map →

All Auto Repair and Mobile Mechanics in Utica

15 independent businesses in our directory.

Getting a Car Fixed in Utica

Independent shops in New York usually charge $110 to $165 an hour for labor, which is above the national average. A quote is the book time for the job times that rate, plus parts. At New York rates, an alternator replacement runs about $290 to $860 and a valve cover gasket replacement runs about $165 to $625 for a midsize car.

Of the 13 Utica listings that post their hours, 6 open on Saturday and 3 on Sunday. 6 open before 8 AM on weekdays, which helps if you need to drop the car off before work.

9 businesses in Utica have at least 15 reviews, enough for a rating to mean something, and 8 of those hold 4.5 stars or better. Half of them have 96 or more reviews. A shop with a long history and a 4.6 is a safer call than a perfect 5.0 from a handful of people.

For work a general shop may turn away, Utica has 4 tire shops and 2 heavy duty and fleet shops. Call ahead with the year, make and model so you do not waste a trip.

Vehicles need a safety inspection every 12 months and when ownership changes. Most inspections also include an emissions check of the onboard computer (OBD). Vehicles less than two model years old or more than 25 model years old are exempt from the emissions part. Details are on the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles site. Repair shops must be registered with the DMV and must give a written estimate if asked. They cannot charge more than the estimate or do any work without permission, and customers can get replaced parts back if they ask in writing before work starts. Read the rule.

Owning a Car in Utica

140Nights a Year at or Below Freezing
44Inches of Rain a Year
20Minute Average Commute
1.27Cars per Household
22%Households With No Car
68%Drive to Work Alone

Lows drop to freezing on about 140 nights a year. Cold is when a weak battery finally fails, because a cold engine takes more power to turn over.

About 44 inches of rain fall in a year. Worn tires lose grip on wet roads well before they look bald, and streaky wipers are a cheap fix worth doing before the wet season, not during it.

The average commute in Utica is 20 minutes each way, and 68% of workers drive there alone. 22% of households have no car at all, which is part of why mechanics who come to you do well here.

Sources, checked October 13, 2026

  • Weather: NOAA U.S. Climate Normals 1991-2020, station Utica Oneida Co Airport
  • Households and commutes: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2020-2024, Utica city

Pre-Purchase Inspections in Utica

Buying a used car in Utica? PPI Auto, our sister company, sends an inspector to the car for $225 on most cars, pickups and SUVs. That is a 122 point check with a full scan and a road test, and the report comes back the same day. Dealer lot, private seller or auction, it works the same.

The nearest PPI Auto city is Syracuse, about 47 miles away, and inspectors drive out to Utica.

New York requires inspections, but a passed sticker only means the car met the minimum on that day. It says nothing about the transmission, the frame or a leak that starts next month.

Questions About Auto Repair in Utica

How many auto repair businesses are there in Utica?

We list 15 in Utica, NY. That covers mobile mechanics, workshops, diesel and heavy duty specialists, body shops and tire shops. Every one has its own page with the phone number, what they work on and the reviews we have found.

Who is the best rated mechanic in Utica?

Meolas Auto Repair currently holds the highest rating in Utica at 5.0 stars from 15 reviews. Meolas Auto Repair, Advent Auto Styling & Customization, Oriskany Garage Tire & Auto Service are the top three by rating among businesses with a real review history behind them. We rank on the ratings themselves and nobody can pay to appear there.

Are there mobile mechanics in Utica?

Yes. 2 of the businesses we list in Utica will travel to you rather than making you bring the car in. That covers most servicing, brakes, batteries, diagnostics and plenty of repairs that do not need a lift.

How much do mechanics charge per hour in Utica?

Independent shops in New York usually bill $110 to $165 an hour for labor. The national range is $95 to $140. Dealers charge more. Most quotes are the book time for the job times that rate, plus parts, so ask the shop how many hours it is billing you for.

Does New York require a car inspection?

Vehicles need a safety inspection every 12 months and when ownership changes. Most inspections also include an emissions check of the onboard computer (OBD). Vehicles less than two model years old or more than 25 model years old are exempt from the emissions part.

Are any mechanics in Utica open on Sunday?

Yes. 3 of the businesses we list in Utica show Sunday hours, including Utica On-Site Truck Repair, Advent Auto Styling & Customization and M & S Auto Electric. Call first, because Sunday hours are often short and some only take emergencies.

How do I know a shop in Utica is trustworthy?

Look at the review count as well as the stars, because five stars from four people tells you very little. None of the 15 listings in Utica has been claimed yet, so call to confirm hours and what the shop works on. Repair shops must be registered with the DMV and must give a written estimate if asked. They cannot charge more than the estimate or do any work without permission, and customers can get replaced parts back if they ask in writing before work starts. Get the quote in writing before any work starts.

Does it cost more to use a mobile mechanic in Utica?

Usually not. 2 of the businesses in Utica come to you, and with no building to pay for, they often charge a bit less than a shop. What they cannot do in a driveway is work that needs a lift or a press, so heavy jobs still go to a shop.

How does winter in Utica affect my car?

Utica gets about 140 nights a year at or below freezing. Cold exposes a weak battery, and salted roads rust brake lines and exhaust parts. Test the battery in the fall and rinse the underbody in winter.

Can I get a pre-purchase inspection in Utica?

Yes. PPI Auto, our sister company, inspects used cars in Utica for $225 on most cars, pickups and SUVs. The inspector comes to the car, runs a 122 point check and sends the report the same day. Call 951-267-8500 to book.

How do I check a mechanic's license in Utica?

Ask the shop for any state or city license it holds and get the estimate in writing before work starts. None of the 15 listings in Utica has given us a license number yet. Rules differ by state, so check with New York's consumer protection office if a shop's answer sounds wrong.

Why do some Utica listings have photos and others do not?

2 of the 15 listings in Utica show a photo or logo. They come from the owner, from the business's own website, or from our own jobs for Supercanic locations. We never put a stock or AI photo on someone else's business. Owners can claim their listing free and add their own.

How does MechanicRank check the mechanics in Utica?

We call, text and email the businesses we list to confirm their details, and listings whose numbers turn out to be dead come off the directory. Nobody can pay to rank higher.

Why use MechanicRank to find a mechanic in Utica?

Because we work with these mechanics, not just list them. Besides checking listings, we run free study guides and certification exams for mechanics, publish repair cost guides by state, and give shops software to send written quotes and invoices. 2 of the Utica listings come to you, 15 carry a rating with the review count beside it, and the order on this page follows the published rules on our How We Rank page.

How this page was made

This page lists 15 auto repair businesses in Utica, NY. We built it from business details and ratings from each Google Business Profile, owner claims and uploads, New York repair and inspection rules from the state agency and Census and NOAA figures for the local car ownership section. We call, text and email the businesses to keep it right, and take listings down when a number goes dead.

Why trust it: no business pays to be listed or to rank, the order follows our published rules, and every count on this page is counted from the listings below. 2 show a photo or logo, 0 show a license number and 0 have been confirmed by the owner.

Mechanics in Nearby Cities

No luck in Utica? A mobile mechanic from the next town over will often make the trip. See all 311 cities in New York.

What Car Repairs Cost in Utica, NY

Typical independent shop prices at New York labor rates, parts and labor, for a midsize car. Each guide shows the price for your vehicle and what to ask before you pay. See all 91 repair cost guides.

FOR UTICA BUSINESSES

Work on cars in Utica?

Claim your free listing to add photos, services, and hours, and stand out from every other shop in Utica with a Mechanic Rank certification.

Not on this page? Add your business free, we review every submission by hand before it goes live.