Mike's Garage

Vehicle repair shop

4.3 4.3 from 358 reviews

Own Mike's Garage? Claim this listing free →

Mike's Garage is an auto repair shop in Tallahassee, FL. It holds a 4.3 star rating from 358 customer reviews. Read the reviews and hours below, or call (850) 574-8988.

Photo from mikesgaragetally.com, this business's own website.

Services Offered

Oil ChangeState InspectionsBrakesHeat or A/CTiresAlignments

As listed on its Google Business Profile. Own it? Claim the listing to set your own list.

Address1881 W Pensacola St, Tallahassee, FL 32304

MapOpen the map →

Phone(850) 574-8988

Websitehttps://www.mikesgaragetally.com/

Also onGoogle Yelp BBB

Good to knowComes to youWheelchair accessible entranceWheelchair accessible parkingOil changesRestroomBy appointment

PaymentsCredit cards, Debit cards, Tap to pay

BBB ratingF View on BBB →

Hours

See the full week

Monday	7:30 AM to 6 PM
Tuesday	7:30 AM to 6 PM
Wednesday	7:30 AM to 6 PM
Thursday	7:30 AM to 6 PM
Friday	7:30 AM to 6 PM
Saturday	8 AM to 1 PM
Sunday	Closed

Mike's Garage Reviews & Ratings

Customer reviews 4.3 4.3 · 358 reviewschecked 2026-09-20

5 star285

4 star8

3 star2

2 star0

1 star63

What Customers Mention

The topics that come up most in its Google reviews, and how many reviews raise each one.

Fair pricing 27Kind staff 19Timely repairs 11Trustworthy mechanic 7Brake repair 5Tire repair 5Spark plug replacement 3Oil leak repair 2

Yelp 10 recent reviews See all on Yelp →

1.0 Kaan U. 2026-06-28 · via Yelp

Here is my honest experience with this place. I brought in a 98 sl500 for basic maintenance after purchasing and driving for a couple weeks. Got new set of tires, oil and battery change. Couple days later the battery was completely flat -…

1.0 Samya H. 2026-05-26 · via Yelp

They will rob you for every penny you have if you let them. I've had the same car for 7 years and I've never had someone try to charge me 1300 for only changing break pads & rotors (nothing else). I almost spat in mike's face after he told…

1.0 Bernard L. 2026-04-15 · via Yelp

A terrible place to get your car fixed. Finally got Mike to pay the judgement owed ($10K - 4/2026) on repairs he did not complete and an engine installed with flaws. Persistence paid off.

Used this repair shop? Leave a review.

Your review appears right here after a quick check. Stick to your own experience — no personal info, no promotion. Your email is never shown.

FOR THE OWNER

Is this your business?

Claiming is free and takes about five minutes. You get to fix the details, add photos, answer reviews, and show a verified badge that puts you above the unclaimed listings in Tallahassee.

Claim this listing free → Add a different business

No card, no contract. Run a shop crew? See the Supercanic franchise program.

Text a Repair AI That Knows Your Car.

Text (413) 288-6349 what the vehicle is doing. It decodes your VIN, checks the open recalls, and walks you through what to check first, in plain words. The first two answers are free.

Text (413) 288-6349

Need Work Done in Tallahassee? Get a Free Quote.

Tell us what the car is doing. A local mechanic calls you back, most requests get a call back the same day. No fee, no obligation.

💬 Request a Mechanic Quote →

What Car Repairs Cost in Tallahassee, FL

Typical independent shop prices at Florida labor rates, parts and labor, for a midsize car. Each guide shows the price for your vehicle and what to ask before you pay. See all 91 repair cost guides.

Transmission fluid change cost $125 to $370 Valve cover gasket replacement cost $150 to $550 Brake pad replacement cost $125 to $360 Timing chain replacement cost $870 to $2,670 Engine mount replacement cost $185 to $810 Coolant flush cost $90 to $215